British MPs Say US-EU Free Trade Deal Must Not Leave Govts at Multinationals’ Mercy


Human Wrongs Watch

10 March 2015 (RT)* — British MPs are protesting the US-EU TTIP free trade deal that could enable multinational corporations to sue governments if newly introduced rules harm their businesses, thus weakening essential European health and food regulations.

**Map: The EU (green) and the USA (orange) shown on a world map. | Author: Ssolbergj | Wikimedia Commons

**The EU (green) and the USA (orange) shown on a world map. | Author: Ssolbergj | Wikimedia Commons

With the help of the Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (TTIP), transnational corporations could impose lax US regulation on EU countries regarding genetically modified crops, use of chemicals in cosmetics and treatment of meat cattle with growth hormones.

The TTIP will also complicate strengthening EU’s environmental and animal welfare regulations, the British parliament’s Environmental Audit Committee (EAC) warns.

In its current form, the TTIP contains an investor-state dispute settlement (ISDS) that allows shareholders and companies to sue countries that “restrict their business practices.”

“EU states must retain their ‘right to regulate’, but a TTIP treaty text that enshrines such a safeguard will be meaningless if the prospect of ISDS litigation produces a chilling effect on future regulation-setting,” the committee said.

Committee chair Joan Walley, a Labour MP, was quoted by The Independent as saying: “Europe must retain its right to regulate. That needs to be embedded in any treaty text.”

The American companies, accustomed to operate in the less-regulated US business climate, are likely to benefit the most from the situation and sue European governments whenever they want to challenge rules they consider are hurting their profits.

This may result in a “race to the bottom” replacement of EU environmental safeguards with weaker US ones, leading to “the lowest common denominator,” The Guardian said.

“Any dispute settlement provision must unambiguously deny US companies any opportunity to sue us when we look to introduce necessary environmental or public health safeguards,” The Guardian cited Walley as saying.

The Conservative-led UK government insists that TTIP will create jobs, open up new markets, boost business and eliminate red tape, but its critics disagree, saying that the treaty provides a way for companies to undermine hard-won workers’ rights and environmental standards.

“The focus in TTIP has been on its potential for boosting transatlantic trade, but that must not be at the expense of throwing away hard-won environmental and public health protections,” Walley warned.

British MPs also pointed out to the lack of transparency surrounding the TTIP negotiations, making it impossible to find out whether environmental risks have been taken into consideration at all.

“What you are doing by including a mechanism like this in a treaty with the United States is you’re increasing the possibilities for firms to challenge you, without actually gaining very much. Investor rights are already very well protected,” Gabriel Siles-Brügge, of the University of Manchester, told The Guardian after giving testimony to the parliamentary committee.

A 2013 report prepared by the London School of Economics for the UK government’s Department for Business, Innovation and Skills found that the ISDS’s presence in the TTIP “is likely to have few or no benefits to the UK, while having meaningful economic and political costs.”

With evidence of the negative effect of the ISDS on the European economy camouflaged in the TTIP, “it is clear that corporations are willing to use the ISDS provision to sue nations for the laws they make,” The Guardian wrote, recalling the ongoing case of tobacco giant Phillip Morris against the Australian government initiated via an ISDS in 2011.

Read more on this issue on RT: 

What part of no don’t you understand?’ TTIP critics target EU trade commissioner

Monsanto agrochemicals cause genetic damage in soybean workers – study

*Source: RT. Go to Original.

**Map: The EU (green) and the USA (orange) shown on a world map. | Author: Ssolbergj | Wikimedia Commons

2015 Human Wrongs Watch

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: