German Interior Minister Calls for Setting Up Refugee Camps in North Africa

Human Wrongs Watch

By Martin Kreickenbaum*, 22 December 2014, WSWS — For weeks, Interior Minister Thomas de Maiziere (Christian Democratic Union, CDU) has been trying to win support for his proposal to set up refugee camps that would be maintained by the UN High Commissioner for Refugees (HCR) in North Africa.

Crisis in Iraq | Source: UNICEF

Crisis in Iraq | Source: UNICEF

He thus takes up an initiative launched more than ten years ago by former British Prime Minister and Labour Party leader Tony Blair and the then-Social Democratic Party (SPD) Interior Minister Otto Schily.

In a television interview on ZDFs Morgenmagazin last month, de Maiziere explained his plans for such camps, describing them in his typically cynical manner as “welcoming and departure centres”.

He said that “what we really need we’ve discussed with EU interior ministers: in the transit countries we need to construct such things as welcoming and departure centres. The UNHCR, the UN’s international refugee agency, could run them and decide who should return (to their homeland) and who can come to Europe”.

Whereas Schily and Blair’s plan to establish internment camps for refugees in Africa sent the media into paroxysms ten years ago, de Maiziere’s plans hardly cause a ripple today.

Only a few human rights organisations have criticised them. Interviewed in the tageszeitung daily paper, Günter Burkhardt, director of the ProAsyl refugee support organisation, expressed alarm at the “apocalyptic vision” of “gigantic tent cities in which hundreds of thousands of people would have to live.”



Thomas de Maiziere claims the refugee camps are intended to provide refugees with a legal way to enter Europe so that traffickers and people smugglers in North Africa will be deprived of their exploitative business practices. This sham argument amounts to pure window dressing.

These measures amount to shredding what remains of the right to asylum in the countries of the European Union (EU).

Internment camps in the African desert, which will offer only a few refugees the prospect of finding asylum in Europe, will not prevent people from taking the dangerous route across the Mediterranean in unseaworthy boats.

“Screening” will be conducted in the camps themselves to provide only a hand-picked number of refugees with shelter in Europe.

ProAsyl rightly points to the example of the Choucha camp in Tunisia, where the UNHCR operates a refugee compound with tens of thousands of refugees, from which only 195 have actually been permitted to travel to Germany.

Basic democratic rights are being undermined in the camps, since the ability to challenge asylum decisions in court is not guaranteed. Neither legal consultation nor legal representation is possible for the refugees.

A child with his mother. Photo: UNICEF/Naser Siddique

A child with his mother. Photo: UNICEF/Naser Siddique

But even if their grounds for asylum were established, the refugees would never get to see Europe, because this would first require an EU member state to declare its willingness to accept them. Just how unlikely that would be is shown by the EU’s firm refusal to accept refugees from Syria.

Finally, the logistics of housing and providing for refugees in North Africa is left completely unclear. It is therefore easy to predict how the camps would look: heavily guarded and fenced with barbed wire, and with the material and medical support for refugees reduced to a minimum.

The EU does not shrink from cooperating with foreign governments to ride roughshod over human rights in its war on refugees, as was made clear by the “Khartoum Declaration” adopted by a conference of interior and foreign ministers of the EU and African Union (AU) in Rome in late November.

More than half a million people have fled Syria for neighbouring countries, even Iraq (Domiz camp, Kurdistan region, Iraq). Photo: Jodi Hilton/IRIN

More than half a million people have fled Syria for neighbouring countries, even Iraq (Domiz camp, Kurdistan region, Iraq). Photo: Jodi Hilton/IRIN

Representatives from a total of 58 states agreed to cooperate closely to bring forced migration to a halt in the countries of origin and transit countries far from the European borders.

This amounts to nothing more than cooperation among police forces, cross-border exchange of information, deportation agreements and the joint construction and operation of “reception centres”. The five-page declaration offers not a single word about “legal ways” refugees might be able to enter Europe.

The EU has forced the African countries into closer cooperation in the campaign against refugees by undermining the right to asylum in exchange for the slight easing of visa or trade provisions.

Documents recently published in Algeria make clear exactly what this will entail. These show that the then-interior minister of the SPD-Green Party government, Otto Schily, had actually put his plans for internment camps in North Africa quietly and secretly into action at least in Algeria.

In Khanke village, Iraq Kurdistan Region, children from the Yazidi minority eat a meal of rice and tomato stew for lunch. Photo: UNHCR/N. Colt

In Khanke village, Iraq Kurdistan Region, children from the Yazidi minority eat a meal of rice and tomato stew for lunch. Photo: UNHCR/N. Colt

As a result of German political pressure, some 56 small “reception centres” for refugees are said to have been secretly established there, some of which are still in operation. Facilities for the project were mainly existing ones used by the United States in its alleged fight against terrorism: secret prisons, torture equipment, and possibly even torture personnel.

The hermetic isolation of the European Union from refugees and its refusal to take in tens of thousands of asylum-seekers is an expression of its historical bankruptcy.

It recalls the time before the outbreak of the Second World War, when Leon Trotsky observed: “The world of decaying capitalism is overcrowded. The issue of the admission of a hundred more refugees is becoming a big problem for a world power of the rank of the United States. In the era of the aircraft, telegraph, radio and television, traveling from country to country is being paralysed by the demand for passports and visas. The period of declining foreign trade and decaying domestic markets is also the period of the monstrous growth of chauvinism, particularly anti-Semitism.”

**Photo: UNHCR/A.D'Amato | Male migrants rescued by the Italian navy sleep in a partitioned section of the San Giorgio military ship.

Photo: UNHCR/A.D’Amato | Male migrants rescued by the Italian navy sleep in a partitioned section of the San Giorgio military ship.

Given the incitement against refugees, migrants and Muslims from whatever source, attacks on refugees and their living quarters are constantly increasing in Germany. In addition to the everyday daubing of swastikas, refugee shelters are once again being deliberately set on fire, most recently in Rostock and Bavarian Vorra.

Such acts are continually sanitized by de Maiziere’s ominous warnings that the hosting of refugees must not to lose sight of the level of “public acceptance”. Such arguments pave the way for the return of Nazi mobs.

*Martin Kreickenbaum’s article was published by WSWS (World Socialist Web Site). Go to Original.

[Statements and views expressed in this article are the author’s and do not necessarily reflect those of Human Wrongs Watch].

Read also:

Refugees Perish at “Alarming” Rate on Dangerous Crossing to Europe – UN

Sinking of Mediterranean Migrant Boat Amounts to ‘Mass Murder’ – UN Rights Chief

Year’s Deadliest Week: More than 300 Die in Boat Tragedies on Mediterranean

Mediterranean, the Deadliest Sea for Refugees, Migrants

Tracing Dead Migrants in Europe

More War Refugees Today Than in World War II — 51 Million

With Annual $36 Billion, Human Trafficking Ranks as World’s Third Most Profitable Crime

1 in 3 Victims of Human Trafficking Is a Child — Girls, Women Account for 70% of the Total

‘Liberated’ Afghanistan: What to Do With Three Million Refugees, Half a Million Homeless

Becoming Refugees Once More: Palestinians from Syria Return to Gaza

Europeans, the Once Upon a Time Refugees!

Who Is Afraid of 300 Or 400 Or 500 Million Miserables?


2014 Human Wrongs Watch

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: