Egypt: Religious Scholar’s ‘Fatwa’ against Protesters Sparks Outrage

Human Wrongs Watch

By Shahira Amin*

Cairo, 17 August – A controversial ‘fatwa’ issued by a prominent Muslim cleric sanctioning violence against anti-Muslim Brotherhood activists planning demonstrations in Cairo on 24 August, has sent shockwaves throughout Egyptian society, triggering public outcry and angry denunciations by political activists and rights groups.

**Mohamed Morsi | Jonathan Rashad

The ‘fatwa’ [a non-binding juristic ruling by Islamic scholars] comes at a time of increasing fears of an Islamist crackdown on freedom of expression as well as reports of physical assaults against journalists critical of the Muslim Brotherhood.

Speaking at a seminar at the Diplomatic Club in downtown Cairo on Tuesday [14 August], Shiekh Hashem Islam, a member of the Fatwa Committee of Al Azhar —  Egypt’s highest Islamic authority, told a gathering of intellectuals, activists, civil society members and journalists that it was a “religious duty” to fight protesters planning to rally against the Muslim Brotherhood next week outside of the presidential palace.

“Deserters” of Islam?

He described them as “Khawarej” — a term often used to describe deserters of the Islamic faith. He reminded his audience that President [Mohamed] Morsi had been chosen by the people and “the world has attested to the fairness of Egypt’s first post-revolution presidential elections”.

He said, “If they kill you, kill them. Those of you killed will be martyrs, but if they die no blood money will be required”.

The Sheikh’s inflammatory words came in response to calls by anti-Islamist activists for a “second revolution” on 24 August against the Muslim Brotherhood.

The activists have been using social media networks to mobilise for the protests which they say are aimed at toppling the Islamist President as well as the Muslim Brotherhood’s Freedom and Justice Party.


Rumours have circulated of possible attacks on Muslim Brotherhood offices but some liberal activists — who have confirmed their participation in the protests — say they want to keep the demonstrations peaceful.

Leaders of the Muslim Brotherhood have been careful to distance themselves from the Sheikh’s provocative statements, insisting the group opposes any calls to violence.

The Brotherhood released a statement today on its English language site, Ikhwanweb, saying that while respecting the right to free expression, individuals calling for “illegal acts of violence, vandalism and destruction of public and private property” during protests will be “held to account by the law”.

Muslim Brotherhood members have in turn said they are considering a rally of their own — the date of which is yet to be determined — to support President Morsi against the threats to unseat him.

The ultra-conservative Salafists have vowed to show their solidarity with the Muslim Brotherhood if such a rally were to be held.

 Harsh Criticism from Politicians and Activists

Sheikh Islam’s inflammatory message meanwhile drew harsh criticism from politicians and activists alike after a clip of the Sheikh’s statements were posted on social networking sites.

Several activists took to Facebook to show their outrage, saying “it was not within the scope of the Sheikh’s authority to issue religious edicts” and that “fatwas should only come from the Grand Mufti”.

Reform activist Mohamed ElBaradei blasted the Sheikh on his Twitter feed saying “if such clerics are not put on trial, fascism will rule masquerading under the guise of religion”.

Liberal MP Abu Hamed echoed the call to place the Sheikh on trial. “This is what happens when we mix religion and politics”, he was quoted as saying by state-owned newspaper Al Ahram.

Aligned with the Military

Abu Hamed is one of the organisers of next week’s anti-Muslim Brotherhood protests, which have also been called for by former MP Mostafa Bakry and TV talk show host Tawfik Okasha. All three are known for their close alignment with the Supreme Council of the Armed Forces (SCAF).

In recent weeks, the anti-Muslim Brotherhood rhetoric of both Abu Hamed and Okasha has only become more venomous.

Okasha is also the owner of Al-Faraeen, an independent TV channel that was shut down by authorities earlier this week on charges of defamation and incitement to violence against the Muslim Brotherhood as well as President Morsi.

Christians Expected to Join Protests

The majority of Egypt’s Christians — who make up approximately 12 per cent of the country’s population — are expected to join the 24 August protests amid mounting fears that their religious freedoms may be restricted under Islamist rule.

Many liberals have also declared their intent to join the rallies, amid rumours that there is a possibility that the protests may turn violent.

An inherent fear of the Muslim Brotherhood — outlawed under the previous regime — and growing concerns amongst secularists that their freedoms may be curtailed under the newly elected President (a longtime member of the Muslim Brotherhood) are key reasons behind mobilisation against Islamist rule.


Morsi’s decision last week to replace the chief editors of state-run newspapers with mostly Islamist-leaning editors and journalists — more likely to adopt the state line without debate — has fuelled fears that the Muslim Brotherhood wish to exercise control over the media and other state institutions.

Dr Shahida el Baz, an independent researcher, warned that “The Muslim Brotherhood are infiltrating state institutions with the hope of eventually asserting their control over key institutions in the country”. She expressed concern that “the group’s non-inclusive policies threaten to undermine the democratic transition”.

Between the heightened tensions, speculations of violence, and a lot of finger pointing, analysts wonder if a second eruption will indeed take place only days from now.

The one thing that’s certain to say is that if a direct confrontation between Morsi’s supporters and his opponents does occur — there will be no winners this time around.

*Shahira Amin is a well know Egyptian journalist and analyst. Currently she is Senior Anchor/Correspondent, Nile TV, and CNN contributor. Amin resigned from NileTV in an open protest against the biased, pro-regime coverage of the Egyptian revolution, which she actively joined in Tahrir Square. Shahira Amin is known for her unwavering defence of freedom, democracy, social justice and gender equality. Her article was first published by UNCUT Index on censorship. Go to Original


**Photo: Mohamed Morsi. Credit: Jonathan Rashad | Wikimedia Commons

Egyptians Return to Tahrir Square to Protest Military Power Grab

Will Egyptian President Be an Islamist, a Leftist, Or the “Devil You Know”?

Egypt — New Reality, Same Old Regime Propaganda

Egypt: New Adverts on State-run TV Play on Fears of Foreigners

Wave of Violence Threatens Egyptian Presidential Elections

It’s Revolution Again in Egypt

Military Trials of Thousands of Egyptian Civilians “Legal”

Egyptian Women Waiting to Reap the Fruits of the Revolution

Military Court Hears Evidence in Egyptian “Virginity Tests” Case

Egypt: No More ‘Virginity Tests’ by the Military

‘Egyptian Women No Longer Satisfied to Walk One Step Behind Men’

Egypt, the Year After – Media Revolution Only Beginning

‘Stop the Military Junta Brutal Attacks on Free Expression’ in Egypt

Egypt: Military Junta, More Repressive Than Mubarak

Egypt: Jubilation, But…

“New Egyptian Parliament to Dismantle Tools of Repression”

Egypt…The Revolution Goes On!

Egyptian Civil Society: “We Need a Secular State”

‘The Egyptian Revolution Was Inevitable And It Is Irreversible’

2012 Human Wrongs Watch

One Trackback to “Egypt: Religious Scholar’s ‘Fatwa’ against Protesters Sparks Outrage”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: