What's in the UN New Gaza Agreement?

GAZA, JERUSALEM, DUBAI, 19 September 2014 (IRIN)* – On 16 September the UN announced a new deal that is supposed to ease restrictions on the Gaza Strip. In his public statement on the day, Robert Serry, the UN envoy for the Middle East, gave few specific details about the deal but said it would “enable work at the scale required in the Strip, involving the private sector in Gaza and giving a lead role to the Palestinian Authority in the reconstruction effort.” IRIN looks at the issues.

Following the 50-day war between Israel and Hamas and other Islamist groups in Gaza, much of the enclave is in ruins. At least 18,000 homes were destroyed as Israel dropped thousands of bombs on the heavily populated area, while key infrastructure including power plants and water networks were also badly damaged.

Rebuilding efforts are made even more challenging by a pre-existing blockade. Since 2007 Israel and Egypt have limited or banned many basic goods from entering the Strip. Among those that Israel restricts are fertilizers, cement, steel cables and even some fabrics. Tel Aviv defines such goods as “dual use” – meaning that while they are needed for the civilian population, they could also potentially be used by militant groups in attacks.

With the catastrophic level of destruction and ongoing humanitarian crisis, rebuilding without easing the blockade is nearly impossible. A key housing group has estimated that without lifting the restrictions on cement and other dual-use goods, restoring Gaza just to the level it was before the war could take 20 years.

As such, the UN, the Israeli government and the Palestinian Authority have reached a deal that seeks to increase access while aiming to assure Israel that none of the goods will fall into the hands of Hamas or other groups that it labels terrorists.

Photo: Ahmed Dalloul/IRIN | Back to school

***Photo: Ahmed Dalloul/IRIN | Back to school

What are the terms?

Not all the terms have been ironed out yet and agreements on specifics – such as cement – have not been made public. Indeed both Israeli and Hamas officials IRIN spoke to were hesitant to talk about the exact terms of the deal.

What is known so far is that there are two main areas of works that this applies to – UN projects and private Palestinian projects. The former have been subject to fewer restrictions in recent years, but a new deal has been agreed whereby the Israeli government will approve UN projects upon receipt of only basic information and their general locations. This, in theory, should speed up UN operations.

The second category – Palestinian projects – is the more contentious issue. Under the new rules, Palestinian businesses trying to bring in “dual-use” goods must first register with a database run by the Palestinian government in the West Bank, not Gaza. This online database will register the import and transfer of items.

There will be two different monitoring procedures – one for small-scale works such as people rebuilding their homes and another for larger private construction projects. Both of these involve UN monitoring teams overseeing the projects.

A young girl waiting to cross into Egypt with her family cries at the Rafah Border Crossing in southern Gaza. Egypt has opened the crossing to allow injured Palestinians to receive treatment. Photo: UNICEF/NYHQ2014-0902/El Baba

A young girl waiting to cross into Egypt with her family cries at the Rafah Border Crossing in southern Gaza. Egypt has opened the crossing to allow injured Palestinians to receive treatment. Photo: UNICEF/NYHQ2014-0902/El Baba

What assurance does Israel have?

Israel says it is concerned that previous “dual-use” materials have fallen into the hands of militants. Paul Hirschon, spokesperson for Israel’s Foreign Ministry, told IRIN they believed Hamas and other groups had siphoned off aid money following previous rounds of violence in 2009 and 2012. “We do not want a repeat of what happened 2 or 6 years ago, where too much of it [funds, materials]. were diverted into terror,” he said. “We need to ensure that the money that is poured into reconstructing Gaza is not simply put into Hamas’s hands and from there converted from above ground to below ground.”

In theory there are a number of mechanisms to assuage the Israeli doubts. First of all, control of the Palestinian side of the crossings is supposed to be handed from Hamas to the Palestinian Authority (PA), which is based in the West Bank. Unlike Hamas, the PA has diplomatic relations with Israel.

“Both Israeli and Hamas officials IRIN spoke to were hesitant to talk about the exact terms of the deal.”

Likewise the online database should allow better tracking of goods once they enter Gaza. In theory this should help prevent them falling into the hands of Hamas or other armed groups. Thirdly, as outlined above, the UN monitoring teams are supposed to oversee projects, thereby ensuring that no goods go astray.

Was Hamas consulted on this deal?

It does not appear that Hamas, the Islamist party that runs the Gaza Strip, was explicitly involved in the agreement and the extent of the consultation with the group is unclear.

Hamas Spokesperson Sami Abu Zuhri refused to discuss the extent of their involvement in the negotiations, saying only that the process should not damage the resistance – the commonly used phrased for the military opposition to Israel.

“We welcome international and other efforts [for the] reconstruction of Gaza, and we urge [international powers] to push these efforts rapidly forward. Meanwhile, we reject any compromise related to our people’s rights and resistance due to this matter,” he said. Pushing through any deal without Hamas’s support may be problematic.

Photo: Ahmed Dalloul/IRIN | Gaza under attack once again (file photo from 2012)

Photo: Ahmed Dalloul/IRIN | Gaza under attack once again (file photo from 2012)

How long will the agreement last?

That depends. Serry was quick to stress that it was a “temporary mechanism” and had not replaced the ultimate goal of both Israel and Egypt lifting the blockade on Gaza.

Talks on that matter are due to take place on 12 October in the Egyptian capital of Cairo, but analysts think that such an agreement is unlikely – at least in the short term. If no agreement is forthcoming in October then this agreement could be the best hope for improving access to Gaza.[This report does not necessarily reflect the views of the United Nations].

*Source: Report by IRIN, a humanitarian news and analysis, a service of the UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs. Go to Original.


**Photo: Wikimedia Commons | At least 18,000 homes were destroyed in the latest Israeli attacks on Gaza | Reposted from IRIN
***Photo: Ahmed Dalloul/IRIN | Back to school
****Photo: Haytham Besaiso/IRIN | The view of bombing from Haytham’s window
*****Photo: Ahmed Dalloul/IRIN | Gaza under attack once again (file photo from 2012)

Read also:

Gaza: 500,000 Children Unable to Return to School

Gaza: Over 370,000 Palestinian Children in Need of ‘Psycho-social First Aid’ — UN

Eyeless in Gaza

​’20 years needed to rebuild homes in Gaza because of Israeli restrictions’ 

UN Rights Council Appoints Commission to Investigate Purported Gaza Violations

Gaza Diary: Life Under Israeli Assault

Recruiting to Kill – It Is Not Just an Israeli War on Gaza

Gaza Blockade “Illegal”, Must Be “Lifted” – UN


UN Secretary General “Alarmed” at Israel’s Announced Seizure of West Bank Land

Israeli Settler Violence Must Be Prosecuted, UN Human Rights Chief

Requiem For Palestine (I): A Conflict Born With A Solution

Requiem For Palestine (II): Can Gruyere Be A Solution?

‘Denying the Existence of the Palestinian People Is an ‘Article of Faith’

UN Urges Israel ‘To Prevent Settler Attacks against Palestinian Villages’

‘Stop Forced Displacement of Palestinians’ – UN to Israel

UN to Israel ‘Stop Violating Palestinian Child Detainees Human Rights’

‘Urgent Need to Further Protect Palestinian Children Against Israeli Violence’

Unequal Under the Law – Interview with Israeli Historian Ilan Pappé

“Forget About Him, He’s Not Here”

“Sharp Rise in Palestinians Uprooted by Israeli Demolitions”

Palestine: Yet Another One Hundred Years of Solitude

Palestinians Without Hope … Once More

Israel Must Remove all Jewish Settlers from Occupied West Bank – UN Inquiry

UN Decries Use of Live Ammunition against Palestinian Civilians

Israel Boycotts UN Rights Forum, First State in History to Ignore Human Rights Review

Is Israel Always Right?

Israeli ‘Operation Pillar of Defence’ – ‘Not Defence but Murder of Unarmed Civilians’

“Israelis Practise Ten Eyes for an Eye and Ten Teeth for a Tooth”

UN Envoy “Alarmed” by Reports of Israeli Settlers’ Attacks on Palestinian Farmers

Shamir, ‘The Most Successful Terrorist Of The 20th Century’

2014 Human Wrongs Watch

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: